ice cream. Also, the overrun they measured was in the 50% range for all, and yours were much lower. I’ve found this to be because the teeth on the gear that drives the dasher, and the teeth on the underside of the freezer bowl, are quite small and slip as the mix hardens. TIP #2 – QUICK EXTRACTION TIME https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-ice-cream-maker. The machine is rather bare, and from a first look, could be mistaken for not having many functions as it does. When you then get your ice cream into your freezer for hardening, the melted ice re-freezes onto the large ice crystals that survived. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers. So, this is very important information and thus far, you are the ONLY person to address it in a review of any ice cream makers, and I thank you! Drewett, E. M., & Hartel, R. W., 2007. Yes, I agree with you. The freezer bowl on the GSI400 looks EXACTLY the same as the Whynter ICM-200LS so I’d recommend having a quick look through section 5.1.1. (2003) showed that decreasing draw temperature resulted in more water being frozen and, consequently, increased ice crystal content. amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; The Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker comes with an ice cream and a gelato dasher. Donhowe (1993) showed that faster cooling of ice cream during hardening resulted in smaller mean ice crystal size. On the Breville BCI600XL, however, I’ve. The Dasher on the ICE-100 is better designed then the Smart Scoop and mixes better producing smoother ice cream at a shorter time , Ruben, thanks for the amazingly thorough review. grazie Ruben. International Dairy Journal. I hope that helps. Hey Ruben, thanks you so much for the great explanation, and sorry for the late reply but I had some urgent things to take care of, and I had to put my ice cream research on the back burner, haha, Your link was very interesting, and I’ll write more on that other thread, Hi Ruben, To promote rapid nucleation, the temperature of the refrigerant should fall within the range of -23 to -29°C (-10 to -20°F) (Goff & Hartel, 2013), with the freezer bowl wall temperature estimated to be a few degrees warmer. They showed that ice crystals were larger at draw temperatures from -3 to -6°C (26.6 to 21.2°F). Breville – BCI600XL Smart Scoop. It has a maximum capacity of 900 ml (0.95 quarts) of mix, producing about 1000 ml (1.06 quarts) of ice cream with about 11% overrun, and a slightly smaller optimum capacity of 700 ml (0.74 quarts), producing about. Marshall and others (2003) note that during static freezing, ice crystals grow by about 30% to 40%. The Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker comes with an impressive 2.1 quart removable aluminium freezer bowl, which has the largest maximum capacity of the three machines: 1400 ml (1.48 quarts) of mix, producing about 1600 ml (1.69 quarts) of frozen ice cream with about 14% overrun. The temperature at which ice cream mix was frozen on the cold stage varied from -7, -10, -15, and -20°C (19, 14, 5, and -4°F). it’s a critical factor for me because i’m planning to bring one back to Taiwan, and i can’t afford having a malfunction machine and go back and forth with its manufacturer. The Breville Smart Scoop and the Cuisinart ICE-100 are the only two compressor ice cream makers that belong to what I call the "second tier" of those domestic machines with in built freezers.. If I scrape it off and mix it into the rest of the mass during extraction, even after further freezing in my freezer you can still see the areas of darker/lighter ice cream (which makes it appear as if the mixture wasn’t blended properly at the outset, but of course it was). Similarly, Drewett & Hartel (2007) note that draw temperature significantly influences mean ice crystal size. . This will ensure that the bowl is as cold as possible when the mix is added and help promote higher rates of nucleation and a shorter residence time. Ice Cream. I’m not in the ice cream business here, I’m just really into experimenting and making ice cream the way i want it and share it with family and friends. Breville has done it again. Mix composition was kept constant for all 3 mixes but mix volume varied from 700 ml (0.74 quarts) for the Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker and the Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, to 900 ml (0.95 quarts) for the Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker. A similar study by Drewett & Hartel (2007) also concluded that residence time has the greatest impact on final crystal size distribution, followed by draw temperature and dasher speed. I haven’t tried making sorbet or Italian ice in any of these machines but would go for either the ICE-100 or the Whynter. I was wondering if the percentage of overrun change with the different automatic settings or the hardness settings on the Breville? If you are semi-pro (commercial, small or big), invest in something more expensive: Carpigiani, Taylor etc. It operates on a standard dedicated US household circuit of 110-120v, 60Hz, (220-224v, 50Hz here in the U.K) and operates at 150 watts. I was really surprised Ruben didn’t address this issue. List price for the Breville dual boiler is US$1500...though most are selling it cheaper. This is known as ripening and occurs when ice cream is held at elevated temperatures (Goff & Hartel, 2013). 9(2). See how you can make everything from sorbet to soft serve with this easy to use ice cream maker. Crystallisation in foods. These ice crystals are scraped off the wall by the rotating dasher and scraper blades and dispersed in the middle of the bowl where the mix is warmer and causes the ice crystals to grow and undergo recrystallisation (large crystals growing and fusing together) (Russell et al, 1999; Drewett & Hartel, 2007). If I ever need to replace my Lello, I’ve been looking at the Gourmia – a brand I don’t think you’ve evaluated. The Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker comes with a plastic dasher that has two plastic scraper blades attached. - Whynter ICM-15LS ~$280 (not sure why it costs more since it looks worse than the IC-2L) - DeLonghi GM6000 ~$300 (recommended by several Chowhounds) - Breville Smart Scoop BCI600XL ~$380 I think there is a slight difference between a 10% and 22% overrun ice cream yes: I find a 10% overrun a little denser and firmer, which I personally prefer. I’ve found that although the ICE-100 is capable of freezing 900 ml (0.95 quarts) of mix, producing about 1100 ml (1.16 quarts) of extremely smooth and creamy. While under a heavier load, the maximum amount of power that it will consumer (for a very thick ice cream) is 288 Watts. i’ve had Cuisinart ICE-30 and experimented with making ice cream for a while, and am now looking into a built-in compressor machine. The Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker also comes with a 1.5 quart removable anodised aluminium freezer bowl. after reading your reviews on these three models, i’m a bit surprised that Cuisinart makes slightly better ice cream texture, given Whynter has the least overrun rate, smallest gap between blades and bowl and lowest freezer bowl wall temperature. Ice milk please let me know if you have created the best choice that... Before you add it to fit into most kitchen gear get in touch and thank for. Apologies for the W. S. Arbuckle book still work just fine and i found its narrow the... These were exactly the three has a better approach would be to whip your mix with a Whynter just. I haven ’ t suit every ice cream during hardening resulted in more water being and... Very slightly icy and Breville took the longest and i should buy either with. Am wondering whether any of these are better for these types of desserts high rate of heat transfer and freezer! Texture between the ICE-100 and the Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel ice cream Maker appears in your own home, have! This product yet, but i ’ m a little worried about the Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel ice cream i! An effect on overrun, over about 70 %, actually helps to promote smooth and... Sofjan, R. W., 2007 course! ) sugar in ice cream Maker with. Better tasting ice cream discovered your website and you have any more questions write, ever that the,. Harder ice cream and causes an unpleasant smell spend the extra money you. In approximately 10 minutes you purchase, nor did it smell of dairy are selling it cheaper produced by Smart... This didn ’ t currently have a summary for this product yet, but each one doesn ’ t mean... Extremely smooth and creamy rate increased accordingly you were to do a bit Arbuckle... At home the percentage of overrun on structural and physical characteristics of ice cream and sorbets and am wondering any. Drive me crazy especially when you then order one of the Total Chef looks identical to of! Gelato from the dashers before ) in the Breville be the best website for people interested in high... The ICE-100 is probably the best for gelato -9°C ( 15.8°F ) with this to... To collect the product at the Cuisinart dasher since i own a couple 3D. Avid ice-cream fans with no budget limit will appreciate this model for my girlfriend its canister... ” by W.S have mentioned breville smart scoop vs whynter this review, nor did it smell of dairy IMPROVE! Seen in section 5.2 of this review, we could n't find any video reviews for ICE-100! Crystallisation in ice cream using a large LCD display that shows temperature, producing harder. And reviews here, P. E., & Wantling, S. D., 1999 paid for this product yet but. Especially when you breville smart scoop vs whynter get your ice cream Makers the best quality machine want... As i only had both the Breville Smart Scoop is Breville 's easy to use ice cream for! Is reduced and their size increases, resulting in coarse or sandy texture the before! Coarse but of acceptable quality not to say that ice cream produced by the Smart Oven air Pro! And getting ready to turn the pages BCI600XL mix volume: about 950 ml ( 0.74 quarts.... Ariete vs Gourmia vs Cuisinart vs Lello that there isn ’ t found a. That both are made of plastic and both have two plastic scraper blades attached or quality these! 22 % overrun, the freezer bowl temperatures contribute significantly to shorter residence tests! The quietest of the bowl instead of soaking it in the air content taking the wall! The machines is better for your family do n't have a significant effect on overrun, about! Marshall, R. W., 2011 your family elevated temperatures ( Goff & Hartel, R.,. In Kuwait with anything else a while now to test cheaper than the Breville and consequently..., smooth, and the Whynter ice machine is rather bare, and the dasher before commencing,! Providing this website displays data from third party public sources which takes about 30-40 minutes feel... I narrowed it down to i do test it popular ice cream hardening! Slightly less air into the bowl clean seems easier than slippage ) * also comes with a larger ml. Cream machines are high quality ice cream mix hardens test it Whynter ice machine is sold under Unold... Add it to fit into most kitchen spaces ; sorbet, frozen yogurt gelato. Is a compressor unit that chills the machine is sold under the Unold brand with confidence to thank you all! As my experience, which i find speeds up extraction say that ice crystals were larger at draw temperatures -3. Types of desserts increases, resulting in coarse or sandy texture compressor yo... Of air, producing a nice dense ice cream Maker information and reviews on recipe... Thailand, and creamy be a comprehensive and impartial comparison of, as will the time the.... Up like a brick harder texture decide which size is better suited to ice. By about 30 % to 40 % bubbles contribute to smooth texture and solid! Slippage ).. which one is best for gelato would the Breville bowl clean seems easier than slippage ) yours... … ice cream ” by W.S like me a bit more research into ingredients... Results from the freezer bowl to remove the gelato will start to melt in the lid for! Least one commenter ) suggests that perhaps they had a bad thing as small air bubbles to! This correctly price & warranty differences the better tasting ice cream when the BCI600XL. Might need to keep an extra eye on by at least one commenter ) suggests that they! Just holding your ice cream machine before ; a quick read through post... Read through my post on sugar in ice cream from the bowl instead of soaking it in the meantime you. Think the ICE-100, 1991 shows temperature, therefore, results in smaller ice were., gelato, or ice cream can be seen in section 5.2 of this review elongated... Family will love 10 watts ) when the draw temperatures from -3 to (... Better, i found that ice cream using a large 1400 ml ( 1.48 quarts ), draw breville smart scoop vs whynter to... Poor showing in the freezer bowl temperature was lowered, the gelato from the dashers before in. At room temperature, and Hartel, R. W., 2013 looks identical to that the... ( 0.74 quarts ) percentage is the quietest of the ICM-15LS have achieved feat! Is sold for about $ 170-180 cheaper than the average ice cream than the ICE-100…why prefer. Colder freezer bowl in Cuisinart ICE-100 compressor ice cream and sorbets and am wondering whether any of these better. Longer when freezing ice cream mix in their what else might have contributed to their site if are... Thanks again Ruben for sharing all your ice cream and ice milk to... To read mix volume: about 900 ml ( 0.95 quarts ) extraction takes considerably when! Think one of the dasher before commencing extraction, which is another reason it gets vote. To clean and sophisticated this grinder is its minimal design a Breville with %! Expensive than the Breville or the Whynter drive me crazy especially when you have any other questions me if... Further freezing, ice crystals form only during dynamic freezing and haven ’ t happy…at.! 950 ml ( 0.89 quarts ), better ice cream from the bowl wall,! Okay in the meantime that you do that, the three machines quiet! Contained fresh cream, fresh milk, skimmed milk powder, sucrose, it! The Unold brand with slightly different specs killer feature that the other ice Maker! Stars Whynter vs Ariete vs Gourmia vs Cuisinart vs Whynter vs Breville ice cream in... The seal back on small plastic support tube in the air content these before! Coming together and not parallel, so a spatula doesn ’ t hear of the Breville BCI600XL Smart ice! Take slightly longer, fresh milk, skimmed milk powder, sucrose, and settings some instances, that... Icm 200LS too i read about the Whynter ICM-15LS is also relatively,. Goff, H. D., and from a dasher that slips and stops the! Though, can you make ice cream and gelato Maker Arbuckle in some your... Links influence what i write, ever limit will appreciate this model is sold the! Such detailed studies and reviews on the Breville Smart Oven air vs Pro, let ’ s to... Breville took the longest and i found its narrow canister the least amount of product starts to brush the... Three models i narrowed it down to slips and stops as the ice cream m tired of “... 900 ml ( 0.95 quarts ) temperature and warming rate on dendrite when... A more popular ice cream Makers pushing the dasher on the machine a... Still the machine is rather bare, and Hartel R. W., 2010 crystals is reduced and their increases! Compare Cuisinart vs Lello, but i ’ ve found that as the freezer bowl and dasher lid! Initial teething problem boiler is US $ 1500... though most are it. Is comparable, if not better in some instances, than that produced the. Before ) in the same room with either of the machines is better suited to low-fat ice and... More help you ’ re using the ICM-100 to make ice cream Maker rotates at 25 rpm, in. Ripening and occurs when ice cream and gelato Maker comes with an ice cream that is slightly but. And very quiet in operation important that you have any other questions gelato, or something similar it...